Countering the mainstream

Substantiative coverage of Pipeline Protests missing from Mainstream Media

by | Aug 31, 2021 | The Edge, Commentary

The eight-year sentencing of Jessica Reznicek, an Iowan Water Protector arrested for her part in the Dakota Access Pipeline protests, has once again spotlighted the criminalization that environmental and climate activists face in the United States. Yet, as the negative ecological effects of these pipeline projects become more apparent, and the attacks on water protectors become more brutal, the mainstream media continues to treat the construction of these destructive pipelines and matters of protester criminalization as non-issues.

While the high-profile Keystone XL pipeline was shut down during President Joe Biden’s first week in office, the Biden administration continues to back several other damaging pipeline projects; according to NPR, “approvals for oil and gas drilling permits on U.S. public lands are on pace this year to reach their highest level since George W. Bush was president.”

Among the many pipeline projects continuing under the Biden administration, Enbridge’s Line 3 pipeline has attracted specific contention. The oil company seeks to abandon a pre-existing pipeline and construct a new, larger system that would transport nearly 1 million gallons of tar sands oil from Canada through pristine, protected Indigenous land, into Wisconsin.

While Enbridge continues its illegal pipeline construction unhindered, the people opposing these pipelines are facing the consequences of the law. Peaceful protesters like Jessis Reznicek face felony charges, excessive police violence, and other and extreme attempts to stop the civil disobedience that is being led primarily by the country’s Indigenous peoples whose sacred lands have come under specific threat from these pipelines. Criminalization of protestors has become more fervent in recent years, with more and more states passing laws that could put peaceful protestors in prison with misdemeanor or felony charges. According to The Associated Press, more than 700 Water Protectors have been arrested since the Line 3 pipeline was approved in November 2020.

Yet, neither police brutality nor the increasingly criminalization of people’s first amendment rights has piqued the interest of the American mainstream media. A search for words or phrases like “pipeline” or “Water Protectors” will bring up virtually no recent results on NBC’s or ABC’s news websites. Following a search for these words, the only result brought up on the Fox News website is a story criminalizing protesters. A search for “Jessica Reznicek” will bring up zero results on all three sites.

On the whole, nearly no substantiative reporting is happening in regard to the crisis of the United States’ destructive oil pipelines. Jessica Reznicek’s attempts to hinder the construction of the Dakota Access Pipeline were labeled as “terrorism.” Yet no similar labels have been attributed to the oil companies that are actively violating treaties with Indigenous peoples and endangering millions of people by constructing large, spill-prone pipelines through major river systems and crucial, natural sources of water.

Enbridge’s $750,000 payout to the same Minnesota law enforcement agencies that have been brutalizing protesters of the Line 3 pipeline has also managed to fly under the mainstream media’s radar. In spite of the crimes, both legal and moral, being committed by oil companies like Enbridge, the mainstream media remains silent.

On corporate media’s inability to outrightly stand with protestors in the face of blatant injustice, Janine Jackson for FAIR summarized:

“Years from now, corporate media may note that Reznicek’s imprisonment came the same week the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change issued a new report that the planet faces climate catastrophe unless drastic efforts are made to reduce greenhouse gases. They will probably not note their own complicity in reporting on pipelines like Dakota Access as “controversial,” while silently abiding that only one side of the controversy is labeled “terrorist” and goes to prison.”

The dangers that the criminalization of peaceful protest pose to the rights of all Americans are too great to be underreported by major news networks. The mainstream media must hold these companies accountable for their actions alongside the activists and protestors putting their safety and freedom on the line to do the same.

Image via Getty Images

More from The Edge

9/11, the ‘Day that Changed Everything’

We still don’t know the story of what happened and why. On the evening of September 10, 2001, New York police officer Adam Hernandez was on patrol in his Greenwich Village precinct when he saw a man smashing car windows with a hammer. It was a random act of violence...

20 Years After 9/11, Mainstream Media Still Lies About U.S. Wars

Following the September 11 attacks 20 years ago, and the subsequent U.S. invasion of Afghanistan in October 2001, the media broadly published pro-war pieces, often lauding U.S. military instigators as saviors amid the nation’s outpouring of furious grief. The next two...

Labor Day Headlines Dodge Workers’ Rights as Pandemic Aid Ends

Unemployment benefits that were implemented to aid workers during the pandemic ended September 6, coinciding with Labor Day. On September 3, the Department of Labor released its weekly unemployment insurance (UI) report, the last before pandemic benefits ended,...

2021 PCIM Interns Celebrate Summer Accomplishments

Desiree Holz (’23) is a Journalism major who spent the summer interning with The Ithaca Voice. Over the course of her internship, Desiree gained more than 10 bylines covering the labor shortage, new city planning developments, and other stories affecting the Ithaca...

For Afghan Women, Again

This struggle of Afghan women and the fight against misogyny is hardly new, and yet new developments are happening. Newly mobilized global feminisms may be emerging. If this can happen, it might just save our planet. Afghan women ask that there be no recognition of...

Media Bash Biden’s Afghanistan Withdrawal, Ignore Supporters

After 20 years of war in Afghanistan, President Joe Biden recently made the decision to fully withdraw U.S. forces from the country. The U.S.-backed Afghan government quickly collapsed and the Taliban, which harbored Al Qaeda before the 9/11 attacks, regained control....

Coverage of the IPCC Climate Report Can’t Stop Now

In moments when the climate emergency’s dire impacts become unignorable, mainstream news can produce appropriately urgent reporting, such as on wildfires and other disasters. But only sustained coverage of humans’ damage to the planet will communicate the depth of the...