“Let Books Be:” Banned Books Week’s 44th Anniversary

On Oct. 6, the Park Center for Independent Media at Ithaca College celebrated the 44th annual Banned Books Week with a discussion panel featuring Catherine Michael, Communications Librarian; Jennifer Spitzer, Professor of English and Chair; and Sean Eversley Bradwell, Assistant Professor and Center for the Study of Culture, Race, and Ethnicity Director,  Department of Education. The event was hosted by PCIM’s Mickey Huff and Marcy Sutherland.

The panel primarily centered around a new PEN America report released on Oct. 5, which centers around book bans within public schools during the 2025-2026 academic year. Altogether, 11,982 books were banned, making it the highest number of recorded bans since PEN America began tracking them in 2021. Of these, 7,370 of the bans were unique titles, and over 4,500 titles were new entries in PEN America’s Index of School Book Bans.

While the K-12 education became the lingering thread of the conversation, it is important to note that K-12 public schools are only the second largest recipient of book challenges, taking 37% of them overall. Public libraries see the highest share of challenges at 51%, followed by public schools, then school curricula at 8% and higher education at 3% of challenges.”

Alongside PEN America, the organization Unite Against Book Bans was repeatedly recommended by the panel. On its website, people seeking to get more involved in protecting the freedom to read can find an action toolkit with an in-depth look at how to unite effectively. The American Library Association has a similar clearinghouse of resources to take action against censorship, as well as a form to report censorship such as challenges to materials, resources, and services.

Project Censored has also categorized a number of activities people can do to take action against book bans. These actions are listed by the amount of time they take and range from five minutes to over an hour.

According to PEN America, 87% of banned books for the 25-26 school year were fiction, and, within the young adult genre, the portion of banned books that were fiction was more than 90%.

“If we’re banning books primarily around fiction, what you’re telling me is you’re trying to ban a child’s imagination to envision a world where they’re not subjugated to forms of marginalization and violence,” Bradwell said. “That’s what that means to me. If I don’t allow you the space to envision a world that could be, and most importantly should be, what I’m really trying to do is make sure that you cannot see a world other than the world that traps and keeps you emburdened in some form of power dynamic that doesn’t allow you the freedom, the flexibility, the liberation, the emancipation to be ourselves.”

In 2025, 39% of banned books centered around experiences of people of color and LGBTQ+ individuals. Additionally, the panel discussed how some of the most challenged books and subjects are about child sexual abuse.

The panel emphasized that many book bannings are performed without much uproar and may fall under the radar of studies like PEN America’s as a result. Bradwell said that, while PEN America lists New York as having zero book bans in schools throughout the 25-26 academic year, he personally knew of multiple instances where titles were quietly banned from school districts. 

Books are also often at risk of a different practice known as silent banning, where the books are not removed from circulation officially, but are rendered invisible to the average library patron and made incredibly difficult to access. Silent bans are near-impossible to collect information on and it is hard to prove when they happen.

Together, Florida and Texas made up 95% of book bans across the United States during 2025. However, this does not mean concern over banned books should be isolated to people within just those states. What happens in just a handful of states can impact the rest of the county, and other states have been looking to Texas and Florida for inspiration. Thirty-six states overall banned books in 2025, spanning across all sides of the continental United States. 

Further, in 2025, the ALA recorded only 3% of book challenges coming from parents and only 1% coming from patrons of a library. The vast majority of book challenges were initiated by pressure groups and government officials. Groups such as Moms for Liberty serve the function of making waves of censorship appear like grassroots, parent-centered movements.

The ALA has reported that 71% of voters within the United States disagree with efforts to remove books from public libraries. No political party polled has a majority supporting censorship in reading. In the same data, 93% of parents believe that libraries play an important role across the United States.

Local action was stressed repeatedly by the panel. While federal legislation or executive orders may capture a news cycle, one’s community is primarily impacted by decisions made in that community. Keeping an eye on local elections and politics, as well as the libraries, organizations, and people in need in one’s own community, is vital. 

“We saw the statistics showing that a majority of people don’t support that this is happening, so it’s interesting to see that there must be a really well-fueled, well-organized, well-funded small group of folks that want to prevent people from seeing things,” Huff said. “We should use our voices to overpower that kind of effort and really stick up for the right to read and the right to know. I would encourage you to get involved wherever you can, or as little or as much [as you can], because we can stem the tide against book bans and other assaults on our democracy, but we need to work together, and we need to do it now.”