Countering the mainstream

Israel and Palestine: Misleading Objectivity in the News

by | May 26, 2021 | The Edge, Commentary

A ceasefire holds after Israel’s 11-day assault on Gaza that killed over 240 Palestinians, including 66 children, and injured more than 1,700 people. Hamas rockets fired on Israel killed at least 12 people. Despite the ceasefire, colonial violence continues, as Israeli security forces backed Jewish settlers in storming the Al-Aqsa Mosque compound Friday and authorities continue evicting Palestinians. Israeli police announced their intent to arrest hundreds of Palestinian citizens of Israel for their participation in recent sit-ins in support of Palestinians in occupied East Jerusalem and the Gaza Strip.

Mainstream news outlets have at times covered these events with appropriate nuance and direct language, though they may use misleading words such as “clash,” “skirmish,” or simply “violence” to describe police attacks and airstrikes. Oftentimes though, corporate media is unwilling to engage more deeply with the conflict, and defaults to upholding the status quo.

Holly Jackson, a junior at Massachusetts Institute of Technology, conducted a recent study analyzing more than 33,000 New York Times articles on Palestine and Israel using machine learning methods. The research, currently in preprint submitted to the Journal of Palestine Studies, shows a history of bias against Palestine in the New York Times, consisting of more negative and violent language in reference to Palestinians and a disproportionate use of the passive voice to describe violence against Palestinians.

This bias affirms the flaws of journalistic objectivity, as a major news outlet that touts “both sides” reporting has shown shown a consistent slant against Palestine. As a FAIR analysis demonstrates, examples in the past weeks abound of mainstream news outlets “presenting a false equivalency between occupier and occupied” and minimizing information that shows the scope of Israel’s brutality. Corporate media have framed Israel’s bombings as a defensive response to Palestinian aggression. But,

“Hamas’ rocket fire was a follow through on its promise to fire rockets in “response” to and “retaliation” against Israel if the latter didn’t remove its forces from the Jerusalem neighborhood of Sheik Jarrah, where Israel has been attempting to force Palestinians from their homes and repressing the resultant protests, and from the Al-Aqsa Mosque compound, which Israel had just raided during Ramadan, Islam’s holiest month.”

Moreover, FAIR’s Gregory Shupak argues, as an occupying power, Israel has no legal right to claim self-defense against the people it occupies. Mainstream reporting creates the false impression that the violence is perpetuated equally by “both sides,” but in this attempt at journalistic balance, it obscures that only Israel has ethnically cleansed, prevented Palestinians from returning to their homes, and enforced apartheid and military occupation.

For some organizations, calling attention to this false balance is a friable offense. Emily Wilder, a twenty-two-year-old journalist who had worked at the Associated Press for three weeks, was fired after making this observation on Twitter: “Using ‘Israel’ but never ‘Palestine,’ or ‘war’ but not ‘siege and occupation’ are political choices—yet media make those exact choices all the time without being flagged as biased.”

A snowballing group of conservative politicians and media outlets criticized the statement, using her words to fuel the right-wing argument that the AP is biased against Israel. Days before Wilder tweeted those words and was fired, Israel bombed a Gaza building housing offices of the AP and Al Jazeera, in another instance of escalating violence against non-state-controlled press.

In Canada, a group of journalists grew frustrated with Canadian media coverage that reported on Israel’s airstrikes without context or Palestinian voices. More than 2,000 people signed the open letter they drafted to Canadian newsrooms. Shortly after it was published, letter organizers heard from journalists who had been called to meet with management at their newsrooms to discuss why they signed. At least three people were taken off coverage of the region. According to ex-correspondent Paul Adams, CBC was one such organization that reprimanded employees and, in some cases, barred them from covering the Middle East.

Columbia Journalism Review’s Jon Allsop wrote of objectivity that critics see tradition as one of its central sins: “privileged perspectives and practices have ossified, over time, into core tenets of journalism, such that deviating from them can be perceived as deviating from journalism itself.” Journalists demanding nuance are breaking from mainstream values, and in so doing, endangering their careers.

Reporting from mainstream news outlets may benefit from reconsidering how “objectivity” colors the conflict between Israel and Palestine. The New York Times has recently published several opinion pieces featuring Palestinian voices, and the Associated Press is slated to review its social media policy after 150 staff members spoke out against Emily Wilder’s firing. Pressure from progressives such as Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Bernie Sanders too may force more critical coverage, especially as the U.S. continues selling billions in arms to Israel. All news organizations must examine if the reality of their “both sides” coverage perpetuates bias against one.


Photo by Hatem Moussa/AP Photo

More from The Edge

9/11, the ‘Day that Changed Everything’

We still don’t know the story of what happened and why. On the evening of September 10, 2001, New York police officer Adam Hernandez was on patrol in his Greenwich Village precinct when he saw a man smashing car windows with a hammer. It was a random act of violence...

20 Years After 9/11, Mainstream Media Still Lies About U.S. Wars

Following the September 11 attacks 20 years ago, and the subsequent U.S. invasion of Afghanistan in October 2001, the media broadly published pro-war pieces, often lauding U.S. military instigators as saviors amid the nation’s outpouring of furious grief. The next two...

Labor Day Headlines Dodge Workers’ Rights as Pandemic Aid Ends

Unemployment benefits that were implemented to aid workers during the pandemic ended September 6, coinciding with Labor Day. On September 3, the Department of Labor released its weekly unemployment insurance (UI) report, the last before pandemic benefits ended,...

2021 PCIM Interns Celebrate Summer Accomplishments

Desiree Holz (’23) is a Journalism major who spent the summer interning with The Ithaca Voice. Over the course of her internship, Desiree gained more than 10 bylines covering the labor shortage, new city planning developments, and other stories affecting the Ithaca...

For Afghan Women, Again

This struggle of Afghan women and the fight against misogyny is hardly new, and yet new developments are happening. Newly mobilized global feminisms may be emerging. If this can happen, it might just save our planet. Afghan women ask that there be no recognition of...

Media Bash Biden’s Afghanistan Withdrawal, Ignore Supporters

After 20 years of war in Afghanistan, President Joe Biden recently made the decision to fully withdraw U.S. forces from the country. The U.S.-backed Afghan government quickly collapsed and the Taliban, which harbored Al Qaeda before the 9/11 attacks, regained control....